When I recently ran out of my favorite eyeliner, Maybelline Unstoppable, I had to immediately to go the store to get more. Apparently a lot of people love this eyeliner as well because I couldn’t find it in black anywhere. After checking again a few days later, and still not having any luck, I decided to try a new eyeliner. The two main things that I look for in an eyeliner are staying power and one that won’t smudge. I want to perfectly smudge my liner myself, not have it do the job for me through out the day. I ended up picking up CoverGirl Outlast Smoothwear All-Day Eyeliner in Onyx. It goes on smoothly, easily, lasts all day without flaking, and doesn’t smudge on it’s own. At all. It’s easy to blend after application. Just use a cotton swab to blend a bit and give yourself a great smoky eye look. After using it for several days, I think that I may have found a new favorite eyeliner.